My wife and I went to try out Jake's Pickup and they were closed only sandwiches in the cooler. We bought two turkey sandwiches, deviled eggs and blueberry crumb cake. It was amazing the sandwiches were great and deviled eggs were so good and also the blueberry crumb cake. I spoke to Jake the owner and I told him we will be back when they're open for hot sandwiches and burgers. Now that we tasted their cold sandwiches will definitely be back.

Great food. Thoughtful sourcing. Ambiance? It's in the back of a gas station market. When Jake and his wife are available, they are very amenable to helping provide what you need. Worth stopping by.

Super cute shop in a gas station convenience store! We had great deli sandwiches and awesome breakfast sandwiches (Fridays only)! Grab the sconenut if you're looking for a treat! Super friendly service as well.

Husband and I did a day trip to Bainbridge and found ourselves hungry for some lunch when I found Jake's Pickup on Yelp. This eatery is located in a gas station, but don't let that deter you. Lots of parking outside and plenty of shaded picnic table seating. Inside, the eatery is located in the corner with a menu of to-order items. They also have a fridge stocked with grab and go items and a pastry window with cookies and scones. Order at the counter, then pay at the gas station till. We decided to order 2 OMC's off their menu. The friendly cashier suggested we add Jake's homemade hot sauce to our sandwiches, which turned out to be a beautiful addition to the sandwich. To my understanding, everything here is made from scratch by Jake, including the buns. The sandwich was super fresh and the hot sauce added a lovely smokiness. We also enjoyed a scone and a cookie, both of which were fresh but okay as sugar was the predominant flavor. I found myself wishing for some flaky sea salt on my cookie to balance the sweetness. All-in-all we will definitely be back on another Bainbridge visit to try more menu items.

Jake's Pickup has become a bit of an island icon with their eclectic and yummy offerings. It's particularly nice that they make many items available for sale even outside of their regular operating hours, so if you get a hankering for something late at night you can just pop by to grab what's on offer. We love that they do custom orders, too -- for example, we wanted a gluten free pecan pie for Thanksgiving one year, and boy did they deliver!

Quick. Fresh. Clean. I didn't have a whole lot of time in between appointments and I needed a QUICK lunch on Bainbridge Island. The quick dining options were limited so I took a chance on Jake's Pickup, located in the convenience store portion of a Chevron station. I chose well. The sandwiches, while grab-and-go, were fresh and tasty. I noticed containers of soup in the refrigerated section that had I a cooler in my car, I would have taken home for dinner that night. The tables outside were clean and a nice place to eat so I didn't risk spilling all over the front of myself by eating in my car.

This is defintiely good if you are a trucker and need some healthy options. But I can't imagine a trucker stopping here. They don't take orders anymore so becareful thinking you can. It's all cold fridged items but it's defintiely fresh. Hard to go wrong with a tuna sandwich, fancy that it's ahi. The salmon salad was quite good, it defintiely got a little mushy on the bottom but the salmon was smokey and great! Great first time experience but I wouldn't come.

I attended an event where Jake's Pickup Grab'nGo catered. The food was delicious and the staff were very friendly. I was glad to learn about this company because they definitely are a great option to consider if planning a casual event that's COVID-friendly. Jake's Pickup had different slider sandwiches and sides where each serving was in a small container, as well as bite-size cookies for dessert. Everything was grab and go as their name suggests, which was especially nice since people could just pick up what they wanted and is mindful of the pandemic, since no one had to use the same utensils to pick up their food, which is the case for most catered food. I had a turkey and roast beef slider with caprese salad and a mac salad. All of these items were tasty, but my favorite was the roast beef slider. It had arugula with a horseradish dressing and the roast beef was perfectly sliced and flavorful. The buns for the sliders were also soft, but held the goods together. I would definitely consider Jake's if planning to have a catered event where people can easily pick up their own food, as everything can be individually wrapped and easy for takeout. Glad to have discovered Jake's, and the next time I'm on Bainbridge Island, I'll have to find their restaurant and discover more of what they offer.

Sconuts. Remember that word. You need this yummy little love child of the demure scone and the devilish donut ASAP. Chocolate chip. Strawberry coconut. Mmmmmm Jake has made his heaven as a baker and chef in the back of a Chevron gas station, and in the process he's put a lustful little grin on a whole lot of surpised faces. Jake makes sandwiches packed with delicious fresh and local ingredients wrapped in homemade bread even anti-gluters enjoy. (He uses non-gmo ingredients and was overheard saying that makes his gluten less troublesome unless you actually have celiac.) His bread craft includes amazing rye, soft buttery burger buns, and the thickest white wheat ever. His sandwich ingredients range from burger to tuna melt and turkey and more breakfast sammies and cinnamon rolls are also on offer. Portions are big. This place is worth a visit. Highly recommend for casual but delicious food.